Guidebook for Amagansett
Food Scene
Here are a few of our favorite places to dine.
Clam Bar At Napeague
2025 Montauk HwyGreat seafood walking distance from house
Romantic restaurant with wonderful menu. Favorites: Ricotta with honey and crab tagliatelle. The location is beautiful. Grab a drink down by the lake while you wait for your table. Weekends are insanely busy so we usually go very early midweek to avoid the crazy crowds. No reservations. We love this place!
94 Einheimische empfehlen
The Crow's Nest
4 Old West Lake DrRomantic restaurant with wonderful menu. Favorites: Ricotta with honey and crab tagliatelle. The location is beautiful. Grab a drink down by the lake while you wait for your table. Weekends are insanely busy so we usually go very early midweek to avoid the crazy crowds. No reservations. We love this place!
Delicious seafood walking distance from house (yes, it's the same one seen in the tv show The Affair. As a result it is now super crowded but still delicious)
91 Einheimische empfehlen
Lobster Roll aka LUNCH
1980 Montauk HighwayDelicious seafood walking distance from house (yes, it's the same one seen in the tv show The Affair. As a result it is now super crowded but still delicious)
The muffins are probably the best I've ever had. This place is great! Delicious food to go. Wonderful pastries. Located in East Hampton near trainstation
56 Einheimische empfehlen
Mary's Marvelous
107 Newtown LnThe muffins are probably the best I've ever had. This place is great! Delicious food to go. Wonderful pastries. Located in East Hampton near trainstation
Wonderful restaurant that takes advance reservations. Good place for families as it's on a pond with a little dock for kids to play while waiting for your table.
74 Einheimische empfehlen
Harvest On Fort Pond
11 S Emery StWonderful restaurant that takes advance reservations. Good place for families as it's on a pond with a little dock for kids to play while waiting for your table.
LT Burger
62 Main StBurgers. Shakes. Salads. Everything is Delicious.
Great reasonably priced Mexican food. Very casual picnic table atmosphere where food is served on trays. Be prepared for long line on weekends. No indoor seating so you may want to take to go in rain.
63 Einheimische empfehlen
La Fondita
74 Montauk HwyGreat reasonably priced Mexican food. Very casual picnic table atmosphere where food is served on trays. Be prepared for long line on weekends. No indoor seating so you may want to take to go in rain.
Great sushi on your way to or from the city. Very popular so be prepared to wait.
26 Einheimische empfehlen
Suki Zuki
688 Montauk HwyGreat sushi on your way to or from the city. Very popular so be prepared to wait.
DOPO La Spiaggia : East Hampton
31 Race LnAmazing Italian food.
Favorite brunch! Salads and quesadilla are our regulars. But everything is delicious. Expect a wait on weekends.
79 Einheimische empfehlen
Estia's Little Kitchen
1615 Bridgehampton-Sag Harbor TurnpikeFavorite brunch! Salads and quesadilla are our regulars. But everything is delicious. Expect a wait on weekends.
Excellent food and service! We love everything - but the tuna tartar and fresh fish specials are extraordinary. Big portions and they take reservations. The ice cream sundae is delicious!
128 Einheimische empfehlen
East Hampton Grill
99 N Main StExcellent food and service! We love everything - but the tuna tartar and fresh fish specials are extraordinary. Big portions and they take reservations. The ice cream sundae is delicious!
BuddhaBerry
125 Main StYUM! Frozen yogurt emporium like nothing I've ever seen.
Duryea's Lobster Deck
65 Tuthill RdBeautiful location on the lake.
Coche Comedor
74A Montauk HwyGreat food close to house in Amagansett. Reservations for larger parties.
29 Einheimische empfehlen
Wölffer Kitchen Amagansett
4 Amagansett SquareGreat food close to house in Amagansett. Reservations for larger parties.
Love the burgers and brunch! Usually can get a table without much wait. Wonderful shakes. Great for families. Reasonable prices.
60 Einheimische empfehlen
LT Burger
62 Main StLove the burgers and brunch! Usually can get a table without much wait. Wonderful shakes. Great for families. Reasonable prices.
Open late. Delicious food. Great for groups. Indoor and outdoor seating. Excellent pizzas and salads. About 30 minute drive from house.
24 Einheimische empfehlen
World Pie
2402 Montauk HwyOpen late. Delicious food. Great for groups. Indoor and outdoor seating. Excellent pizzas and salads. About 30 minute drive from house.
Scarpetta Beach
290 Old Montauk HwyRestaurant in Gurney's overlooking beach.
Tillie's
290 Old Montauk HwyRestaurant in Gurney's with great brunch.
Drinks & Nightlife
Great music. Super popular. Very fun if you want to go out.
136 Einheimische empfehlen
The Stephen Talkhouse
161 Main StGreat music. Super popular. Very fun if you want to go out.
The Surf Lodge
183 Edgemere StMusic and food. Very popular place.
Si Si is located on the harbor and has an incredible sunset view. They also take reservations. The greek salad, mushroom pasta and grilled lobster are wonderful!
16 Einheimische empfehlen
Sí Sí Mediterranean Restaurant
295 Three Mile Harbor Hog Creek RoadSi Si is located on the harbor and has an incredible sunset view. They also take reservations. The greek salad, mushroom pasta and grilled lobster are wonderful!
Spas and Exercise
There are lots of exercise and spa options in the area. Here are a few of our favorites.
Great yoga in a beautiful convenient space.
19 Einheimische empfehlen
Mandala Yoga Center for Healing Arts
17 Amagansett SquareGreat yoga in a beautiful convenient space.
Wonderful yoga. It's a little bit of a drive and the classes can be quite crowded. We love Colleen's class.
25 Einheimische empfehlen
Yoga Shanti Sag Harbor
32 Bridge StWonderful yoga. It's a little bit of a drive and the classes can be quite crowded. We love Colleen's class.
Regal UA East Hampton Cinema
30-38 Main StYoga Lila Montauk
12 S Etna AveParks & Nature
We love this one mile hike through the dunes which is located close to our home.
17 Einheimische empfehlen
Walking Dunes
We love this one mile hike through the dunes which is located close to our home.
Camp Hero Road
Camp Hero Roadbeautiful Montauk views / walks
A beautiful trail through winding woods and bay. 1.7 mile loop. Follow the road behind the house straight one mile to the entrance / parking lot. We love this hike! Certain times of year, careful of chiggers and ticks.
Promised Land Road
Promised Land RoadA beautiful trail through winding woods and bay. 1.7 mile loop. Follow the road behind the house straight one mile to the entrance / parking lot. We love this hike! Certain times of year, careful of chiggers and ticks.
Napeague State Park
Lazy Point RoadSpas
Excercise classes, spa services, food and a great location
56 Einheimische empfehlen
Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa
290 Old Montauk HwyExcercise classes, spa services, food and a great location
Naturopathica Healing Arts Center and Spa
74 Montauk HwyONDA BEAUTY
42 Main StA Japanese spa with wonderful hydropools, treatments and food. I highly recommend the outdoor hydropools which are completely private for you and your guests along with a sauna and infra red sauna. A very special respite
8 Einheimische empfehlen
Shou Sugi Ban House
337 Montauk HwyA Japanese spa with wonderful hydropools, treatments and food. I highly recommend the outdoor hydropools which are completely private for you and your guests along with a sauna and infra red sauna. A very special respite
Essentials
East Hampton Bagels
76 N Main StBig basic grocery store
Brent's General Store
8 Montauk HwyLocal grocery store
CVS
38 Pantigo RdPharmacy located about 10 minutes drive from house
Farmer's Markets
Balsam Farms Montauk Market
662 Montauk HwyAmber Waves Farm Market & Kitchen
367 Main StLots of activities for the family. Seasonal apple picking, corn maze, pumpkin picking. farmer's marked with baked goods and prepared food.
9 Einheimische empfehlen
Hank's Farmstand
324 County Rd 39ALots of activities for the family. Seasonal apple picking, corn maze, pumpkin picking. farmer's marked with baked goods and prepared food.