La casa es muy bonita y super bien ubicada, a metros de la playa y del centro comercial.- El anfitrión super receptivo siempre y muy amable.- Lo único que falló en nuestro caso fue la limpieza, recién vino alguien a hacerla al día siguiente de nuestra llegada.

La maison de Luis est idéalement placée au sein de l'ile et offre un bon rapport qualité/prix pour Pines Fire Island. Des efforts sont à réaliser sur la propreté.

Overall a great experience! I'd never been to FI before and Luis and everyone staying there was very friendly and accommodating. The house is lovely and close to everything. The room was spartan but very comfortable and I didn't need anything fancy. Would definitely go back!

The host canceled this reservation 2 days before arrival. This is an automated posting.

Luis and his husband were friendly and welcoming. That said, the home feels like something that they are running with their left hand. Refrigerators not turned on...on ice upon (URL HIDDEN) internet service. The last straw was a shower with virtually no water pressure. I reserved and paid for two nights but stayed for just one. Luis et al mean well, but it's not a professionally run guest home.

The host canceled this reservation 5 days before arrival. This is an automated posting.

Luis was great host. Definitely will be staying there again.

Luis is awesome! We had a great time staying here.

Ben was a kind and gracious host. The apartment was super cute and very comfortable. Thanks Ben, we enjoyed out stay!

Fantastic experience! The place was great - everything we needed and more! Clean, really comfortable bed, giant couch, amazing little terrace! Ben was so helpful before we arrived and throughout our stay. Sayville was lovely - easy access by ferry to Fire Island, wine tasting by bike etc! We will definitely come back. Highly highly recommended!

Our stay was pleasant. Ben was a gracious host. We really appreciated that he provided bikes for our use during our stay. It was about a 25 minute bike ride to the ferry to Fire Island. The accommodations were mostly comfortable. The bed was comfy, the place was very clean and we had a little fridge and a coffee maker wth coffee provided. The only thing was that on occasion we could hear (and smell the food of) people on the other side of our bedroom door cooking in the kitchen late at night. Upon arrival, Ben warned us about the kitchen being right there, though. Overall it was a nice stay.

Ben made our first Air B&B experience a perfect one! His place is immaculate and exceptionally charming. Great location. I walked to the Sayville train station several times alone and was there in about 5 minutes. He's a fantastic host too. Kind, considerate and extremely helpful. Took our reservation at the very last minute and was more than accommodating. Comfortable and cozy, super big couch, cable TV, wifi, fridge and coffee maker and extra pillows/blankets for that added at-home feeling. Hope to come again the next time I'm in town.

Our stay in Sayville was great, and Ben was a wonderful host. The guest room is a perfect set up with a separate entrance and lovely, clean space. We loved the welcome, pick up and drop off from the LIRR station, and location. We would definitely book a stay here again!

Highly recommend this spot! The space was very beautifully decorated and everything is new. Everything you could possibly need is there, and I was very impressed at the attention to detail Ben was a very gracious and helpful host, and even gave us a ride to the ferry terminal at Bay Shore, which I thought was above and beyond.

Ben是个热情负责的人,房间干净舒适,去镇子上也很方便,步行几分钟就到,我很喜欢这里,坐在院子里晒太阳的感觉很美好。

Brook landing was an incredibly ideal accommodation for our weekend getaway to fire island. Ben made sure to provide us with anything we needed including bikes, beach towels, and even a ride to town! We cannot have asked for a better, cleaner place and were very happy with our stay.

We had a fantastic time!! Daniel and his team were polite and welcoming. The weather was not good, and we still loved our stay. The Chandelier Room is everything you need for a pleasurable experience and the outdoor shower is an added plus!! We'll certainly return!! Thanks guys!!

Great stay. Brad was so lovely and helpful. Location couldn't have been better. Would definitely stay again.

Had a great stay in Daniels chandelier room. Loved the decor!

Excellent having a private entrance with my own private bathroom! And the hot tub was an added bonus!!

Had a great stay!

Had a great time this is a very gay house with friendly staff Sam was very cool and helpful! The chandelier room is fun but dark and if your straight couple bed is little weird but we asked about this and were moved no problem to a cosy comfy loft room has great sleep. House steps from beach and bars everyone friendly definite worth checking out!

Wonderful! Met us at the docks and showed us around - very warm and welcoming! Thanks!!!

We had a great stay. The room was clean and comfortable and the outdoor amenities (shower, bar and hot tub) were great bonuses. Sam and Daniel were both friendly and accommodating. Staying here is like every gay boy's fantasy of what summer camp should be! :) We would definitely return.

Jacqueline and her husband William were lovely hosts. My girlfriend and I visited their home for a little getaway from the hustle and bustle of the city, and that’s exactly what we got! All stages of the booking experience went very smoothly. From the moment I was confirmed, to the moment we checked out, Jacqueline was always available to answer any questions or concerns. When we first arrived, keys were left for us in a convenient location, light sounds of a podcast played in the living room, pastries and fruit left for us on the kitchen table, our room made, and fresh towels left folded for us on the dresser—now that’s what I call service! We spent the day on Fire Island (the Sayville ferry is a 5-8 minute walk from their home) and returned in the evening to a plate of charcuterie and a bottle of wine with a note that read, “enjoy!” As if this 5-star treatment wasn’t enough, breakfast was made for us the following morning. A couple of Williams “signature” pancakes were just what we needed to hit the beach. The entire experience was so relaxing and welcoming. I would recommend Jacqueline and William’s home for anyone looking to spend some time away. It honestly felt as though we borrowed someone else’s grandparents for the day.

Our weekend getaway in Sayville and Fire Island was perfect, thanks to Jacqueline and William! They were the perfect hosts, accommodating, generous and sweet in every possible way! We were the very first guests, as they just posted their home when I was checking Airbnb in the area, and I would love for other people to know what a great option this is. First, their home is beautiful, warm and decorated with taste, sort of an antique jewel box (and large). They are truly welcoming and offer you access to the entire house, from the porch and garden (with bathtub), to the living, dining and reading area, kitchen and bathrooms (there is a large bathroom upstairs, with a full bathtub!, right next to your bedroom; and there is another with shower on the ground floor, perfect for after the beach, with an appropriate mermaid theme). Breakfast was delicious: great and plenty of coffee, you can choose croissants and jam, or granola cereals and banana, or english muffin and peanut butter..., Their home is in a prime location, really close to the ferries! You just walk for about 7 min and there you are by the boats to Fire island. We didn't come by car, so they even picked us up and left us at the train station on the last day. All in all, I cannot stress enough how wonderful our experience was this 4th of july, a relaxing and worry-free weekend away from the city with two wonderful souls, merci encore Jacqueline and William!

Bill and Jacqueline were the best possible hosts. they came to pick us up at the train station and welcomed us with warm pastries! The house is really nice and clean. They helped us with everything. Amazing end of the stay with a bottle of wine in the patio. Recommended to everyone!

Jacqueline and Will were fabulous hosts!!!! Warm accommodating and interesting! Their home is a large lovely Victorian.... With tons of porches, books, nooks and charm. The short walk to the bay and just a little further to where the ferries leave for fire Island.

Jacqueline and William are the most amazing host you can ever have, their house is 7 minutes walk to the Sayville ferry, their neighborhood is as lovely as their house, our room was very clean and tidy. William picked us up at the train station and Jaqueline cooked an delicious breakfast for us in the morning. Perfect location to spend the day at Fire Island.

Absolutely delightful hosts! We were greeted with such warmth, fascinating conversations and of course with wine & cheese on the porch. Jacqueline & Bill are incredible people, and it's worth coming to Sayville just to meet them. Beautiful historic house, comfortable room. Couldn't ask for a better stay!

Glenn was a fantastic host. He was sweet and helpful and everything was as promised. We were able to book last minute for a midweek getaway in August. The nice thing about this house is that it is basically 5 guest rooms with en-suite bathrooms and a shared kitchen and patio separated from the main house. A huge plus to have our own bathroom. The location is awesome - a 4 minute walk from the ferry dock and a 4 minute walk from the beach. We had a wonderful experience and look forward to going back! Glenn also knows quite a bit about the architecture in the Pines, so if that is your thing be sure to pick his brain!

Description was accurate, and Glenn was really accommodating with check-in/check-out. I'd go back!

Glenn is a very nice person, we enjoyed very much meeting him. the island is gorgeous, it was a pleasure staying there and have a rest !

yes..Glenn made me feel very welcome......he was very nice.liked the property.....good location and pother guests very pleasant...can`t wait to go back.....

Great place to crash in the Pines for the weekend. Definitely more comfortable and accommodating than The Hotel by ShareGurl in the harbor. Clean and comfy room with a private bathroom.

Glenn was a good host. He was communicative and available to answer any questions I had about the space. The house was in a great location, a very short walk from the canteen, grocery store, ferry, and the beach which is all you really need while staying in the Pines.

Everything was great! Room was exactly as described. A tight fit, but the perfect place to crash in FIP. Glenn was very accessible and we had everything we needed. Very clean, great shower, A/C , and bed was super comfy.

Wonderful rental. Beautiful house that is nicely decorated. Great location that is close to everything. Glenn was warm and welcoming, and very helpful before and during my stay. I would definitely stay here again!

My friend and I stayed at Tina's home in Sayville for a weekend getaway to Fire Island. Tina is friendly, responsive, and helpful. The location is convenient without being in a busy area; exactly what we were looking for! This isn't a full-time rental so it felt very welcoming while also being very, very clean. Tina's yard was breathtaking! The veggies and flowers and chickens... Just beautiful. I wish we could have stayed there longer and will definitely be back!

Tina was terrific helping me to secure the reservation. I had a bit of a time with it and she helped me get through it! Tina's home is spotless and very peaceful and beautiful. We especially loved her gardens, full of birds and butterflies and we felt right at home seeing her little flock of chickens. The location is perfect for anyone using the LIRR. No more than a 5 minute walk from the station. Note her street is not marked. It is a one way street on the right and her home is just down on the left. Continue down her street, go right, and you wind up back on Main Street where there are a lot of nice shops and a really neat place for weekend brunch called Cafe Joelle. Delicious! To take the ferry to Fire Island, go back to the LIRR station and take the shuttle $5, and about a 10 minute ride to the Ferry. Made for a really enjoyable weekend. Thanks Tina!!

Tina was such a wonderful host. Her home was so inviting, neat, and convenient for the nearing area. Her backyard garden was so beautiful and relaxing, and the chickens with fresh eggs was a nice touch too. Tina's home was perfect for a near by romantic get away not too far from the beach and a cute shopping town. The food in the area was amazing, I recommend Blackbirds Grille

Tina was a great hostess: she responded readily to all our questions and had a friendly and easy manner. The property itself was like something out of a fairy tale. A tree with a human face greeted us, and the gardens were alive with birds, butterflies and bees. We spent a couple happy evenings sitting in the porch, listening to the cicadas going crazy and made countless visits to the hens. The house itself was spic and span, airy and light. The location in Sayville is great. Close to the train, near the stores and in a lovely lane. Sayville itself is a fun place to be, convenient to the Fire Island ferries and with a charming beach of its own. Yes, we'd return.

wonderful home, quiet and centrally located. highly recommend it.

Tina has a wonderful home and this is an excellent place to stay. Her Garden is immaculate and she has all the comforts one could want. Highly recommend.

I stayed at Tina's desperately needing an escape from the city. Tina's house was everything I needed. It was a bit more suburban than my stays upstate or in the Berkshires, but that made it easy to take the LIRR and easily access restaurants and the ferry to Fire Island by foot; no car necessary. Her yard is LOVELY and I really enjoyed hanging on the wrap-around porch and reading. Definitely recommend!

Tina's house is the coziest in town. It was such a lovely surprise for us with all the amenities it had. A garden with crops, chicken house to pick up freshly laid eggs and a grill. 5 minute walk to the LIRR and around 20 mins walking to the ferry to Fire Island. There are a bunch of places around to dine and get groceries. Everything was clean and in order when we arrived. Will definitely come back next time.

my friend and I came to the pines for 5 days and had a great time at Luis'. The house is great, having an outdoor shower was perfect when coming back from the beach. everyone we met couldn't have been nicer or more accommodating. I would come back asap.

Great place and location and Luis was super helpful.

Great place. Good location, nice deck, very friendly hosts.

Luis and his husband were super sweet and great hosts. We ended up hanging out together the entire weekend. Luis went above and beyond to make my birthday weekend special. Thank you!

Great location, friendly host and very comfortable room. We had a great time and definitely will come again.

It's a fairly basic 1960's beach bungalow with lots of windows in the living areas. The house is a bit far from the harbor but quite close to the beach. The living room is an open plan space with a decent retro kitchen and furnishings. The bedrooms were a bit dark and the bedroom's A/C although a portable stand alone unit was adequate. The water pressure on the showers should be improved.

Had a very relaxing Memorial Day weekend at Jesse's. The location is great and the house itself is just as described. Super close to the beach and the dock/bars, but then again, Fire Island Pines is tiny. It was a full house that weekend so Jesse wasn't around, but he was very nice and accommodating. A friend of his stopped by very regularly to check that everything was in order. Very satisfied! Only thing to note is that it is a 4 bedroom/1 bathroom. With possibly many people staying there simultaneously, you have to mindful of your bathroom usage, but it wasn't a problem at all while I was there.

We had an amazing weekend at this perfectly located sweet home right by the ocean. Jesse and Katie were great hosts and the house was just perfect for first timers in the island. The location is absolutely superb - a 1 minute walk from the beach, at the part of the island that's closer to Cherry Groves, and 5 minutes walk from the dock. The amenities are pretty basic, but it was more than enough for us. I definitely recommend it!

I thoroughly enjoyed my visit at Jesse's. He immediately made me feel right at home and the others who were staying there were friendly. It was a nice vibe all in all. He has two great decks where you can hang out and listen to the surf, which is just 3 houses away. My bed was super comfy.

Jesse was a delightful and warm host with a beautiful, light, and airy home. He was very welcoming of our needs and of our dog. The home and rooms were clean and we felt we were not restricted to any one area. The location is convenient to the Pines dock and also to the beach. Several times we walked to Cherry Grove as well, which was a short trip.

Jesse was awesome host. Place is well maintained and located. Makes you feel like you are part of a Fire Island share. The other guests were cool as well and atmosphere of the house is social.

We had the best time with Jesse, thank you again for sharing your slice of heaven in the Pines with us. Can't wait to go back, definitely recommend staying at Jesse's place!

John's place is fantastic and just steps from the beach. He and his wife are very welcoming and accommodating. It's the perfect spot for a weekend getaway with your significant other or a friend.

John's place is perfect for a stay in Fire Island. Close to the beach, with a lovely patio in the garden. Watch the birds and butterflies while listening to the sound of the surf. The apartment itself is cozy and clean, and feels nestled in, tucked into a natural setting. John was a perfect host, friendly and welcoming.

Enjoyed this place even more the second time, especially outside. The front deck table area under the umbrella stayed dry even during a rain. The outdoor shower came in handy too. The area is quiet enough to leave the windows and doors open to continually let the outside air inside. John once again was a friendly and accommodating host. I hope for the chance to return.

John's guest house is the perfect escape for a weekend on Fire Island. It is very private and while it is a bit cozy, it has all you need and is the right size for up to two guests. We loved the fact that there was a grill on the patio and John let us use it! The chaise lounge chairs on the deck were also great. We also loved the little encapsulated outdoor space behind the bedroom, it is very private and makes you feel very much like being a part of nature. The house is a mere one minute walk to the beach, and plenty of long towels are provided in the apartment that you can use. Overall, it was exactly what I was hoping to find and I would love to stay with John again some time in the future.

Made to feel very welcome by lovely host/couple. Idyllic quiet spot with secluded shady garden and deck. Still very close to night life if you want it and the beach. Easy to get to from ferry 5-10 mins walk Host provided usual amenities and filter coffee as a bonus. Good advice on local bars/eateries shops etc. All of fire island expensive so this flat reasonable value

John was a great host. His apartment was just as depicted in the photos: very charming and enjoyable. The neighborhood was clean, quiet, and a great oasis from NYC. He responded very quickly to messages and was very kind by allowing us to check out later than the listed time because there were no new guests expected that day. I would definitely choose to stay here again if I returned to Fire Island. Thank you John!

The studio is a perfectly comfy and cozy place to stay in Fire Island. Small private listings like these are hard to come by and so it fills a nice niche for a solo traveler or a duo. I would say the location is absolutely perfect. Just far away from town to feel privacy, but close enough to walk in and make the Pantry before closing or grab a beverage at Low Tea. Proximity to ocean is great. I would walk out to the beach on Nautilus with my coffee and breakfast since it really is so close. There is a simplicity to the studio, don't expect any frills or luxuries, but it is soulful and unique, this modest perch in a beautiful garden. The outdoor shower is basic, but it is there and certainly welcome, the two burner stove is sufficient for low-maintenance cooking, fans keep the space cool, there are enough kitchen tools to make small meals work, the fridge is a great size and a freezer for making ice and keeping ice cream. The bed is comfy. There's a grill and having use of the washer-dryer lifesaving as nothing fully dries in the humidity and it's great to be able to dry towels for multiple days of beaching. This humble spot is a beach shack in the most honorable and affectionate senses of the term, a great value for the high-priced Pines set on a quiet and peaceful walk near the ocean and close enough to town for creature comforts. Recommended.

Johns studio was exactly as I expected. It had an extra lovely patio plus had great access to the beach.

My husband and I stayed at Arsen's place last weekend. It was our very first AirBNB experience. We have been coming to Fire Island for years, but this was ALSO our first time staying in a rental. Arsen was very welcoming and open with his home. He gave us a tour of the entire place when we arrived. We also had some other guests staying in the other 2 rooms that were really awesome as well. Overall, we felt very welcome and comfortable hanging around the house, as well as coming and going as we liked. Everyone there was great. The room and house are better than the photos. We would definitely go and stay with Arsen again.

Arsen was a gracious host to say the least; kind, caring, charming. My friends and I had a great time. House is beautiful, well styled, and in very good condition. Perfect location as well. Nothing but positive feedback, I'll definitely come back for another visit.

Arsen was in contact on the phone before we arrived and answered all our qustions about what to bring and the acomodations. The rooms and the entire home was clean and neat. The kitchen and shared facilities were spotless and fully stocked with dishes pots n pans and amenities. We changed rooms to the two double beds and it was very comfortable. My private bath was brand new and modern. I felt like I was in a modern brand new home.

Amazing first trip to Fire Island! Arsen was a fantastic host and the house was amazing and as described on the site. Great location to everything. Arsen made us feel very welcome and it was nice to socialise and eat together at the house. We can't wait to go back x

Great place, greatly well located and amazing host!

The host canceled this reservation 34 days before arrival. This is an automated posting.

Arsen is a very nice host and has a very charming and comfortable house.

Arsen was a great host and his house was beautiful - inside and out. Would recommend for any other couples looking to enjoy FI Pines. He even volunteered to make us some delicious burgers!

The host canceled this reservation 25 days before arrival. This is an automated posting.

Robert was so nice and accommodating. He put out breakfast every morning and was very quick to help with anything we needed. The house itself could use a little work, but the location couldn't be better.

Very accommodating and great experience overall!

Jack was an incredible host, and his house was lovely! Stayed with a friend for the weekend, and felt very welcome and comfortable. The location is great, just a couple minute walk from the ferry. Will definitely consider staying with Jack again (and for a longer period of time!) for my next trip to the Pines.

Jack was a excellent host from the time I stepped off the ferry till the day I left to go home. He welcomed me to join him and his friends everywhere they were going to be, as well as let me do what I wanted to do on my own. The room and the house were perfect. I will definitely be returning several times this summer. If your looking to meet new friends and have a great place to stay this is the place to do it.

I've just left Jack's place after my 1st weekend on FIP. The house is super conveniently located on the island, and Jack is a great host. The house is friendly, clean, and in typical repair. Very good experience!

Everything was just as described, Jack was very accommodating of my arrival and departure times, and the home is very conveniently located to town and the beach. Jack is also a very welcoming host, made sure the guests had the opportunity to meet each other, and gave me lots of suggestions of fun things to do the weekend I was there (my first visit).

We are very happy to stay with Jack for the second time. We felt like we were in our vacation home. Would love to go back again.

We stayed in Jack's house for Labor Day weekend and we had a great time. Jack is a fantastic host, amicable and responsive. We had trouble turning on the BBQ grill, and he went out to get a new gas tank and made it work. We would love to stay in his place again.

The house was exactly as described. David was easy to contact and was flexible on a special request regarding date of arrival. The house was exactly as described in the listing. It was quiet and private but just close enough to the harbor--I loved the nearly tame deer on the walk to and from. I was always happy to see the ducks near the pool, and I could spend hours sitting in the hot tub looking at the lights across the bay. The kitchen was well-equipped, the beds were comfortable, and I really liked the outdoor shower. Overall I had a great stay!